FCC’s plan to scrap old cable rules ignites fierce fight over streaming

The Federal Communications Commission is set to vote on simplifying decades-old cable TV regulations, but the move highlights a much bigger, messier war over whether live TV streamers like YouTube TV should face the same rules—a battle that pits the cable industry against its old allies in the wireless lobby.

Same screen, new rules: The push to regulate streamers is being championed by FCC Commissioner Nathan Simington, who argued in a recent essay that services like YouTube TV and Hulu + Live TV should be treated just like cable companies. This would saddle streamers with the same obligations that have long defined traditional cable, including negotiating carriage fees with local broadcasters and carrying PBS stations for free.

Former friends, new foes: The debate unfolds amid an even fiercer battle over wireless spectrum, where the cable industry now finds itself in the crosshairs of a former champion: ex-FCC Chairman Ajit Pai. Now heading the wireless industry’s top lobbying group, Pai is campaigning for more 5G spectrum, arguing in a Wall Street Journal op-ed that the U.S. has fallen behind China and that a new spectrum auction could raise $200 billion.

Calling the bluff: That claim drew a sharp rebuke from Spectrum for the Future, a coalition that includes the very cable companies Pai once championed. The group called his fundraising estimate “absurd” and his arguments “wrong on the facts,” pointing to recent statements from wireless CEOs who claim to be sitting on “years and years and years” of unused spectrum. The coalition blasted Pai for “stunning hypocrisy” in pushing for the U.S. to adopt the same kind of state-aligned spectrum policy he warns against in China.

A tangled web: A simple regulatory vote is just the opening act for much larger, intertwined battles that will determine how streaming media is regulated and who controls the future of wireless communication. Meanwhile, the debate over streaming’s future goes beyond regulation, with one FCC commissioner laying out his full argument for a level playing field. At the same time, the fight for wireless spectrum now involves national security concerns over naval operations. And to see what’s at stake, look no further than Miami’s airport, which is already using the contested spectrum to power its own private network.

Reading Recap:

• See the FCC’s full meeting agenda

• Read the argument for regulating streamers